Local art clubs tend to have beautiful posters, gorgeous show flyers, and the most boring renewal email on earth. Every spring, the notice lands in members’ inboxes looking like a utility bill. Plain text. Default font. One line that says, ‘Your membership is due.’ For a group of people who care deeply about how things look, that’s a missed chance.
A renewal email is a small piece of brand design, and it might be the most important one the club sends all year. So, let’s take one apart, top to bottom, the same way you’d critique a poster. To keep things concrete, we’ll use an imaginary group called the Riverside Sketch Club.
Table of Contents
Before you open any tool, decide what this email needs to feel like. Riverside is friendly, a bit messy, and proud of its charcoal-smudged Tuesday nights. A sleek corporate layout would feel like a stranger wrote it.
Pick three things from the club’s existing identity: one color, one typeface and one texture. That’s your whole kit.
Then think about legibility. The US Web Design System suggests at least an effective 16px for most body copy. Honor that, even if a smaller size looks more refined on your screen. Many of your members may be reading on a phone, and some of them have been painting for 50 years.
Color needs the same care. WCAG asks for a contrast ratio of at least 4.5:1 for regular text. This catches out a lot of artists. Say your signature color is a sunny yellow like #F2C14E. On white, I measured it at about 1.68:1, so it’s great as a border or a shape, but useless for text. A deep brick like #B5412A hits about 5.59:1 on white, so it passes for text and for buttons.
Here’s the part designers tend to skip. Before you draw a single box, find out what the club actually sends from. Most small groups don’t hand-code emails. They use a platform for managing memberships, and that tool decides how much control you get.
WildApricot, for example, offers customizable email templates and automatic renewal reminders, along with invoices and recurring payments. That matters for design. If reminders go out automatically, your work has to live inside a template, and it has to look right for every member without anyone touching it.
So ask the club’s volunteer admin a few plain questions first. Can we edit the header? Can we change the button color? Can we insert a member’s name or expiry date? The answers will shape your layout far more than any moodboard. Design for the template you have, not the one you wish you had.
Now let’s build it. Here’s every piece, in the order a member sees it.
This is your headline. Skip “Membership Renewal Notice.” Try “Keep your easel, Maya: renew by May 1.” Short, personal and clear about what you need.
Keep it slim. Use the club’s logo at a modest size, and don’t let it push the message down the screen. On a phone, the first thing people see should be about them, not your logo.
Here’s your secret weapon. You have a whole club of artists, so use their work! A member’s sketch from last season beats any stock image. Ask permission, credit the artist and keep it wide and short, so it doesn’t fill the entire screen.
If it carries meaning, describe it in the alt text. If it’s purely decorative, the W3C says to use an empty alt attribute so screen readers can skip it.
Display fonts are where the personality lives, but not every email app will load them. Custom type can quietly fall back to Arial. So set the headline in your display typeface as part of the image, then use a safe system font for the body copy. Add the same words to the alt text.
Three short paragraphs, tops. Remind them what they got this year, say what’s coming next and give the price and the date. Write it like the club secretary would talk, not like a bank.
One button. One job. “Renew my membership” in your brick color with white text. Make it big enough for a thumb, and keep the same button on every reminder, so that people learn it.
Don’t forget the boring stuff. The FTC says marketing emails need a valid postal address and a clear way to opt out. A pure renewal reminder may count as a transactional message, but the rules treat mixed messages as commercial if they read like promotion. Add the address either way, and ask someone qualified if you’re unsure.
A single notice is rarely enough, because people mean to renew and then forget. Plan a short series that shares the same design, but shifts in tone.
You wouldn’t send a poster to the printer without proof. Treat this the same way. Send a test to yourself and to two members who aren’t especially tech-savvy. Open it on a phone, on a laptop and in dark mode. Turn the images off and see if it still makes sense.
Then watch the numbers. WildApricot-style tools can show who opened and clicked, so you can tell whether the design is doing its job. If everyone opens the email but few click, your button or your message needs work.
A renewal email will never hang in a gallery. But when it looks and sounds like the club, it does something a plain notice can’t. It reminds members why they joined in the first place, and that’s what gets them to stay.
Keep your creative ideas flowing with more insights and inspiration from our blog
Unlock freebies for your creative projects. Explore a curated selection of fonts, graphics, and more - all absolutely free. Don't miss out, claim yours now!
Claim Free Freebies
